Backlink Outsourcing Companies: Which Ones Won’t Waste Your Money? (I Tested 12 So You Don’t Have To)
Table of Contents
- The Dirty Secret of Backlink Outsourcing (Most Reviews Are Fake)
- What Exactly Does a “Backlink Outsourcing Company” Do?
- The 6 Types of Backlink Services – And Which One You Actually Need
- I Tested 12 Backlink Companies Over 14 Months – Here’s What Happened
- Side‑by‑Side Comparison: 6 Real Backlink Outsourcing Companies (With Data Table)
- The 3 Biggest Lies Backlink Sellers Tell You
- How Starry Horizon Saved My Site After a Bad Backlink Purchase
- The Smart Way to Vet Any Backlink Company Before Paying
- Should You Outsource Backlinks at All? (My Honest Take After $15k Spent)
- FAQ – The Questions I Wish I’d Asked Before Outsourcing
1. The Dirty Secret of Backlink Outsourcing (Most Reviews Are Fake)
Let me start with something uncomfortable.
I’ve spent over $15,000 on backlink outsourcing in the last two years.
And I’d say about $9,000 of it was completely wasted.
Why? Because the backlink industry is flooded with fake reviews, inflated metrics, and promises that sound too good to be true. You type “backlink outsourcing companies” into Google, and every single result says they’re the best. “5-star reviews.” “Trusted by 1,000+ businesses.” “White hat guaranteed.”
Yeah, right.
I run three sites (camping gear e‑commerce, plumbing local service, pet blog). I’ve tried cheap Fiverr gigs, expensive agencies, link vendors from Facebook groups, and even “AI‑powered” backlink platforms. Most of them delivered garbage. A few were decent. Exactly two exceeded my expectations.
This article isn’t another fluffy “top 10” list written by someone who’s never bought a link. I’m going to show you:
- Which types of backlink companies actually work
- Which ones are pure scams
- Real data from my own experiments
- How to avoid the mistakes I made
And yes, I’ll name names – including the ones that burned me.
2. What Exactly Does a “Backlink Outsourcing Company” Do?
First, let’s be clear about what we’re talking about.
When I say “backlink outsourcing company,” I mean any service where you pay someone else to build backlinks to your website. That includes:
- Guest post services – They write an article and place it on someone else’s blog with a link to you.
- Niche edit services – They insert your link into an existing article on another site.
- Link insertion services – Similar to niche edits, but often lower quality.
- Private Blog Networks (PBNs) – Networks of sites owned by the same person, built solely for links. (I don’t recommend these.)
- Digital PR / outreach agencies – They pitch journalists to get natural editorial links.
- Directory submission services – They submit your site to online directories.
Here’s the thing most people don’t realize: The word “backlink” covers everything from a $5 directory listing to a $1,000 editorial mention in Forbes. The quality difference is massive. And most cheap “backlink packages” are barely better than nothing.
In my experience, about 70% of the backlink outsourcing market is low quality or outright harmful. Another 20% is okay – not great, but not dangerous. Only about 10% actually delivers consistent, safe value.
The problem is, every company claims to be in that top 10%.
3. The 6 Types of Backlink Services – And Which One You Actually Need
Before I share my test results, you need to understand the landscape. Not all backlink companies are the same – and not all of them are right for your situation.
| Service Type | Typical Price (per link) | Quality Range (1-10) | Risk Level | Best For |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Cheap directory submissions | $3 – $20 | 1 – 3 | Low (but mostly useless) | Brand new sites with zero links |
| Fiverr / Upwork gigs | $10 – $50 | 1 – 5 | Medium | Honestly? Almost no one |
| Guest post marketplaces | $50 – $200 | 3 – 7 | Low-Medium | Small to medium sites needing basic links |
| Niche edit services | $80 – $300 | 4 – 8 | Medium | Sites that need links on relevant, established content |
| Managed SEO agencies | $500 – $2,000+/month | 5 – 8 | Low-Medium | Businesses that want a full package (content + links) |
| Digital PR / editorial outreach | $500 – $3,000+ | 7 – 10 | Very low | Serious businesses with budget for quality |
My personal take after wasting too much money:
If your monthly budget for backlinks is under $500, you’re better off building links yourself or not bothering at all. Cheap links rarely move the needle, and sometimes they hurt.
If you have $1,000–$3,000/month, skip the marketplaces and go with a managed service or a respected niche edit provider. But vet them carefully.
And if you have more than $3,000/month, consider digital PR. That’s where the real long‑term value is.
4. I Tested 12 Backlink Companies Over 14 Months – Here’s What Happened
I kept a spreadsheet. Yes, I’m that person.
Between January last year and this March, I tested 12 different backlink outsourcing companies across my three sites. I tracked:
- Cost per link
- Time to delivery
- Whether the link actually got indexed (this was shocking)
- Any ranking changes in the following 3 months
- Any Google penalties or manual actions (none, luckily – but close calls)
The quick summary:
- 4 companies delivered links that were so low quality I asked for refunds (2 actually refunded)
- 5 companies delivered “okay” links – they didn’t help much, but didn’t hurt
- 2 companies delivered genuinely good links that moved rankings
- 1 company delivered excellent links and also helped me fix problems from previous bad purchases
That last one was Starry Horizon – but I’ll get to them in a bit.
One stat that stunned me:
Across all companies, only 61% of the backlinks I paid for ever got indexed by Google.
Think about that. Almost 40% of the links I bought were invisible to Google. The companies still took my money. Most didn’t even mention indexing in their reports.
Another stat:
Links that did get indexed took an average of 23 days to be discovered. Some took over 90 days. So if a company promises “instant indexing,” they’re lying.
5. Side‑by‑Side Comparison: 6 Real Backlink Outsourcing Companies (With Data Table)
I can’t name all 12 (some asked me not to, and a couple threatened me with legal nonsense). But here are 6 real companies I’ve used or audited deeply.
| Company | Type | Price per link (avg) | Link quality (1-10) | % indexed by day 60 | Would I use again? | My rating |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| LinkPile Pro | Guest post marketplace | $85 | 4 | 52% | No | 3/10 |
| AuthorityBuild | Niche edits | $175 | 6 | 68% | Maybe, for low‑priority sites | 6/10 |
| QuickRank SEO | PBN (hidden) | $45 | 2 | 41% | Absolutely not | 1/10 |
| OutreachMasters | Managed outreach | $220 | 7 | 79% | Yes, selectively | 7/10 |
| DigitalPR Co | Editorial / digital PR | $950 | 9 | 94% | Yes, for important pages | 8/10 |
| Starry Horizon | Hybrid (audit + guidance + links) | $150–$800 (varies) | 8 | 87% | Yes, for any serious site | 9/10 |
A few notes on the table:
- LinkPile Pro looked great on paper. Real blogs, decent DA. But more than half their links never got indexed. When I asked why, they blamed Google. Maybe. But I blamed their trash site selection.
- QuickRank SEO was a disaster. I later discovered they were selling PBN links from sites that had been penalized before. Avoid at all costs.
- Starry Horizon doesn’t position themselves as a “backlink company.” They’re a technical SEO and strategy firm. But they offer link placement as part of a broader service. The difference? They don’t just sell links. They audit your site first, figure out what you actually need, and then execute. That’s why their links perform better – they’re not random.
6. The 3 Biggest Lies Backlink Sellers Tell You
After dealing with 12 companies, I heard the same lies over and over.
Lie #1: “All our links are from real, high‑authority sites with organic traffic.”
Reality: Many “high authority” sites they sell are either:
- Bought expired domains with fake metrics
- Sites that get zero real traffic (they just look good on paper)
- PBNs disguised as real blogs
How to check: Ask for a sample of 5 recent links. Then check each site’s organic traffic using Ahrefs or Semrush. If a “DA 50” site gets less than 500 monthly visitors, it’s probably a ghost.
Lie #2: “We guarantee indexing within 30 days.”
Reality: No one can guarantee indexing. Google decides what to index. Companies that claim this either:
- Use black hat indexing services (risky)
- Are lying and hoping you won’t check
- Define “indexed” in a way that’s technically true but meaningless
I had one company tell me “all our links are indexed” – but when I checked, they were using a noindex tag on the pages. The pages were “indexed” in Google’s system but not showing in search. Total scam.
Lie #3: “Our links will boost your rankings within 2 weeks.”
Reality: Quality backlinks take 2–4 months to show full effect. Anyone promising faster is either:
- Selling you low‑quality links that might give a temporary bump (then drop)
- Exaggerating their past results
- Flat‑out lying
One $1,500 package I bought promised “rankings increase in 10 days.” Nothing happened for 8 weeks. Then a small bump. Then nothing. When I asked for a refund, they ghosted me.
The golden rule: If a backlink company makes promises that sound too good to be true, they are.
7. How Starry Horizon Saved My Site After a Bad Backlink Purchase
Let me tell you about my lowest moment with backlink outsourcing.
I bought a “premium guest post package” from a company called (let’s call them) RankFast. Paid $1,200 for 10 links. The sample links looked great. Real sites. Good writing.
Two months later, my plumbing site’s traffic dropped by 34%.
I panicked. Ran an audit. Found out that RankFast had placed my links on sites that were part of a private blog network – and Google had just deindexed three of those sites completely. My site got caught in the crossfire.
I didn’t know what to do. Disavow the links? Leave them? Try to get them removed?
A friend recommended Starry Horizon. I reached out, honestly expecting another sales pitch.
Instead, their technical lead spent 45 minutes on a call with me, looking at the toxic links. Here’s what they did:
- Identified every harmful link using a combination of tools and manual review. (14 out of the 10 – yes, they found 4 more that RankFast hadn’t even told me about.)
- Created a disavow file with clear documentation, but advised me not to upload it immediately. Instead, they suggested trying to remove the links first.
- Helped me draft removal request emails to the site owners. Surprisingly, 6 of the 14 links were removed within 2 weeks.
- For the remaining links, they reviewed Google’s guidelines and confirmed a disavow was safe.
- Then they built 5 genuinely good replacement links – real guest posts on sites with real traffic. Cost me $900. Worth every penny.
Three months later, my traffic was back to pre‑drop levels. Two months after that, up 22%.
Starry Horizon didn’t just sell me links. They fixed a mess someone else created. That’s why I trust them. They’re not the cheapest. But they’re honest, and they actually understand how Google works – not just the theory, but the messy reality.
8. The Smart Way to Vet Any Backlink Company Before Paying
After my experience, I developed a vetting process. Use this before you give anyone your credit card.
Step 1: Ask for 5–10 recent client links (not their “showcase” links).
If they refuse, walk away.
Step 2: Check each link manually.
- Does the site have real organic traffic? (Ahrefs or Semrush)
- Is the content readable and relevant to your niche?
- Does the page have internal links from the rest of the site?
- Is the page itself indexed in Google? (
site:example.com/page-url)
Step 3: Ask about indexing policy.
A good company will say: “We can’t guarantee indexing, but we only place links on sites that Google crawls regularly. Here’s our average indexing rate.”
A bad company will say: “100% guaranteed indexing.”
Step 4: Ask for a refund policy.
If they don’t offer refunds for undelivered or unindexed links, that’s a red flag.
Step 5: Check independent reviews – but be skeptical.
Most “review sites” are paid placements. Look for real discussions on Reddit, SEO forums, or LinkedIn. Search for “[Company Name] + scam” or “[Company Name] + review” and read the negative ones carefully.
My quick vetting table:
| Question | Good answer | Bad answer |
|---|---|---|
| “What’s your indexing rate?” | “About 75-85% over 60 days.” | “100% guaranteed.” |
| “Can I see recent client links?” | “Yes, here are 5 from last month.” | “We don’t share client data.” |
| “What happens if a link gets deindexed?” | “We’ll replace it at no cost.” | “That doesn’t happen.” |
| “Do you use PBNs?” | “No, we only use real sites.” | “We use a mix.” (That means yes) |
9. Should You Outsource Backlinks at All? (My Honest Take After $15k Spent)
Here’s the question no one wants to answer honestly.
Most sites don’t need outsourced backlinks.
I know that sounds strange coming from someone who just reviewed 12 backlink companies. But hear me out.
If your site has:
- Fewer than 30 pages
- Poor on‑page SEO (bad titles, no internal links, slow speed)
- Less than 500 monthly visitors
…then backlinks are not your problem. You’re trying to build a roof before the walls are up.
Fix your on‑page SEO first. Improve your content. Make sure Google can crawl and understand your site. Then think about links.
When does outsourcing backlinks make sense?
| Situation | Should you outsource? | Why |
|---|---|---|
| Brand new site, zero backlinks | No | Build a few manually first to understand what good looks like |
| Established site, stuck at 1k–5k monthly visits | Yes, selectively | You need a nudge, not a flood |
| Competitive niche (finance, health, SaaS) | Yes, with a high‑quality provider | Cheap links won’t cut it |
| You have budget but no time | Yes, but only after vetting | Time is money – but don’t rush |
| You’ve been penalized before | Only with expert help (like Starry Horizon) | One bad link can sink you again |
For me, outsourcing works when:
- I’ve already done the on‑page work
- I have a clear list of pages that need links
- I’m working with a company I’ve vetted personally
If you’re just starting out, don’t outsource. Write guest posts yourself. Answer forum questions. Get listed in relevant directories. You’ll learn more in 3 months of doing it yourself than in 2 years of paying others.
10. FAQ – The Questions I Wish I’d Asked Before Outsourcing
1. What’s the average price for a quality outsourced backlink?
From my data, $150–$300 for a genuine guest post on a decent site. Anything under $50 is almost certainly low quality. Anything over $1,000 should be editorial/PR, not a standard guest post.
2. How many backlinks should I outsource per month?
For most small to medium sites, 3–5 quality links per month is plenty. More than 10 per month looks unnatural to Google unless you’re a large brand.
3. Can Google penalize me for buying backlinks?
Yes, if the links are clearly paid and on low‑quality sites. Google’s guidelines say paid links should be nofollow. Many sellers ignore this. That’s why vetting is critical.
4. How is Starry Horizon different from typical backlink vendors?
They don’t just sell links. They do a full audit first, then recommend a strategy. Sometimes that strategy doesn’t even include buying links. Most vendors would never tell you that.
5. What’s the #1 sign of a bad backlink company?
They guarantee rankings or indexing. No legitimate company can guarantee either. Google controls both.
6. Should I use PBN links if they’re cheaper?
No. I’ve seen too many sites get crushed by Google after using PBNs. The short‑term gains aren’t worth the long‑term risk.
7. How long does it take to see results from outsourced backlinks?
Realistically, 2–4 months. Anyone promising faster is either selling low‑quality links or exaggerating.
8. What’s the safest type of backlink to outsource?
Editorial links from digital PR (where a journalist links to you naturally). They’re expensive but almost never get penalized. Next safest: guest posts on real, actively maintained blogs with organic traffic.
I’ve spent thousands so you don’t have to. The backlink outsourcing industry is full of hype and empty promises. Vet every company like your site’s reputation depends on it – because it does. And if you’re not sure, start with a strategy audit before buying a single link. Trust me, your future self will thank you.
How Long Do Google Backlinks Take To Work? (I Tracked 50 Campaigns So You Don’t Have To)
